
Crisis communications has traditionally focused on risks that arise from something an organisation has done, failed to do or been accused of doing, whether that is a product failure, corporate misconduct, a cyberattack, an environmental incident or the behaviour of a senior leader.
Increasingly, however, businesses are having to think about a different source of reputational risk, one that may have very little to do with their own behaviour and much more to do with the actions of the country with which they are associated.
A decision taken overseas can alter how customers, politicians, regulators and other stakeholders see a business, leaving companies dealing with the consequences of events in Washington, Beijing or Brussels that they had no involvement in and little ability to influence.
A different kind of reputational risk
At Cavendish Consulting, we call this Nationality Exposure, by which we mean the effect a company’s perceived nationality can have on its reputation and on the way its stakeholders respond to it.
At Cavendish Consulting, we call this Nationality Exposure, by which we mean the effect a company’s perceived nationality can have on its reputation and on the way its stakeholders respond to it.
The idea itself isn’t new, wars and international disputes have long led to boycotts and hostility towards businesses associated with particular countries. What is clear is that the combination of trade tensions, economic nationalism, restrictions on technology and greater scrutiny of foreign investment means companies are becoming caught up in these disputes more frequently.
Earlier this year, we commissioned research among the British public and MPs to understand attitudes towards nationality and what they could mean for companies operating in sectors including technology, health, energy, infrastructure and defence.
Asked which countries posed a risk to Britain’s national interests, 37% identified China, while the United States was only six percentage points behind on 31%, and among younger respondents the US was seen as a greater threat than China.
Those attitudes also appear to have an effect on what people are prepared to buy. A third of British adults, 33%, said they were less likely to buy from US companies, while 41% said they were more likely to buy from EU businesses; among MPs, meanwhile, 85% supported tougher scrutiny of foreign companies bidding for UK public contracts.
Nationality can work in a company’s favour as well as against it, with European origins, for example, attracting positive associations among some audiences, but the wider implication is that where people think a company comes from can influence how they judge it, independently of what the company itself has actually done.
When companies become stand-ins for governments
Consumers can’t do much to change another country’s foreign policy, trade policy or approach to international affairs, but they can decide where they spend their money, which means companies can become a convenient and highly visible outlet for frustration with governments.
We have seen this in Canada, where anger over US trade policy has prompted boycotts of American products, with similar sentiment emerging elsewhere, leaving individual businesses to deal with commercial consequences arising from political decisions in which they played no part.
Companies can’t change where they come from, but they can do a great deal to shape what that means to the people who matter to them.
There is also a less obvious risk for crisis communicators to consider, because nationality may influence not only whether a company becomes the focus of public anger but also the way it is treated when an unrelated problem occurs.
Take a US business dealing with a serious data breach. At a time when attitudes towards America have become more sceptical among some audiences, it is reasonable to ask whether customers, politicians and other stakeholders would give that company the same benefit of the doubt as a European competitor, or whether wider views of the US would make its explanation harder to land and the crisis harder to contain.
What companies can do about it
Our research suggests companies aren’t powerless here, with attitudes improving when businesses could demonstrate a tangible contribution to the UK through employment, investment in local communities, paying UK taxes, British leadership or partnerships with local organisations.
The important point is that these cannot simply be communications messages developed once a crisis has begun, because claims about jobs, investment or local commitment will carry far more weight when stakeholders have already seen the evidence and regard the company as having a genuine stake in the UK.
For businesses headquartered elsewhere, the objective should not be to play down or disguise their origins but to build a much fuller understanding of the role they play in Britain, so that their nationality is only one part of how customers, politicians and other stakeholders see them.
A company that employs significant numbers of people in Britain, invests here, pays taxes, works with British organisations and contributes to local communities has a much stronger foundation to draw on if its country of origin suddenly becomes politically contentious.
By the time a crisis breaks, it is too late to begin establishing that record, which is why nationality needs to be considered as part of the longer-term work companies do to build reputation and relationships rather than simply as an issue for the crisis communications plan.
A question for the risk register
Nationality Exposure should therefore form part of reputational risk planning, particularly for international businesses operating in politically sensitive sectors or those whose home country is becoming more prominent in political and public debate.
Nationality Exposure should therefore form part of reputational risk planning, particularly for international businesses operating in politically sensitive sectors or those whose home country is becoming more prominent in political and public debate.
That means understanding how the company’s nationality is perceived by different audiences, where sensitivities are greatest and which political or geopolitical developments could alter those attitudes, while also being clear about the evidence the business could draw on if its nationality became an issue.
Jobs, investment, taxes paid in the UK, local partnerships and a demonstrable contribution to British society all matter, but they are considerably more credible when they are part of an established reputation rather than claims being assembled in response to a problem.
Companies can’t change where they come from, but they can do a great deal to shape what that means to the people who matter to them.
Author: Gareth Morgan is Executive Director, Corporate Affairs at Cavendish. He advises organisations operating within complex political, regulatory and reputational environments, helping them navigate external pressures that increasingly shape commercial outcomes, investment decisions and long-term growth. With more than 20 years’ experience advising boards, senior leadership teams and political stakeholders, he supports multinational organisations including Starbucks, General Dynamics, Infosys and Amex GBT on issues spanning geopolitics, public policy, stakeholder risk, corporate reputation and market positioning. Alongside his advisory work, Gareth has worked within think tanks and advised senior Labour figures on national elections, political strategy and internal leadership contests.
Image: AI generated
