
Last year, the Ipsos Reputation Council Report identified Strategic Silence as an emerging trend, with communications and corporate affairs leaders preferring to stay quiet on potentially divisive issues. That trend now looks firmly entrenched.
If last year proved that communicators were no longer trying to steal a reputational march on competitors by taking a stance on a hot topic, this year’s findings show a major shift towards caution. 61% say that even if their organisation could speak up in a legitimate way, they would prefer to stay quiet on divisive issues – and it’s not just theoretical. One-third (35%) admitted that in the last twelve months, their organisation had stayed quiet on issues that it previously would have spoken out about, and almost a quarter (22%) admitted they had consciously under-communicated credible ESG progress.
Strategic Silence should not be confused with passivity. In many cases it reflects a deliberate judgement that speaking carries greater reputational risk than staying silent. Almost half of Council Members (46%) say populism represents a material risk to their organisation and 84% say they take political factors into consideration before deciding whether or not to speak publicly on an issue. In a volatile environment where organisations are being rocked by unpredictable external shocks, many communicators see little value in creating avoidable risks of their own.
Strategic Silence should not be confused with passivity. In many cases it reflects a deliberate judgement that speaking carries greater reputational risk than staying silent.
This is one of the key themes running through Ipsos’ brand new Reputation Council Report, Life After Predictability. In 200 in-depth conversations with communications and corporate affairs leaders around the world, it is striking how little alarm turbulence now generates. As one Council Member put it, “Nothing surprises me anymore.” Developments that would once have been considered extraordinary are no longer viewed as interruptions to business-as-usual – they are business-as-usual.
The consequence is that communications leaders are being valued less for crafting messages and more for helping organisations navigate ambiguity. In a world where certainty is scarce, their role is defined by judgement. Rather than acting primarily as responders to events, they describe their role as helping organisations interpret a rapidly changing environment, identifying emerging risks and opportunities, and making decisions under conditions of uncertainty – all skills traditionally associated with crisis communications.
The consequence is that communications leaders are being valued less for crafting messages and more for helping organisations navigate ambiguity.
Geopolitical fragmentation has transformed corporate communications into an instrument of risk management. Top-down directives no longer work, so while headquarters can set global guardrails and a universal purpose, local teams need the freedom to navigate their own political environments. At the same time, different stakeholders expect different, often contradictory, things from the same organisation. This is shifting the communicators’ focus from finding consensus to judging which trade-offs are acceptable and what backlash their organisation can afford to absorb.
Geopolitics and stakeholder fragmentation are not the only factors raising the premium on judgement. AI is reshaping how reputations are formed, understood and challenged, mediating what stakeholders learn, believe and share about organisations. When misinformation can spread at warp speed, trust becomes more valuable to build up in case of crisis, but harder to earn.
Communicators are already using AI; the question is whether they can use it well. As production becomes easier, judgement becomes the differentiator: deciding what should be said, when it should be said and whether it should be said at all. AI excels at producing communications material, but it struggles to know if anything should be produced in the first place. The importance of stakeholder knowledge and contextual understanding is therefore rising rather than falling.
As production becomes easier, judgement becomes the differentiator: deciding what should be said, when it should be said and whether it should be said at all.
That distinction matters. There is a world of difference between asking, “Could AI do this?” and asking, “Should AI do this, under what conditions, with what evidence, and with whom accountable if it goes wrong?” The test should be whether AI is being matched to real problems, governed according to real risks, and used in ways that improve the quality of decisions rather than merely the speed of output.
That is why communications needs to be more than a user of AI. It needs to be part of how AI is governed. Technology and operations teams will always be better placed to show what AI can do. Communications and reputation leaders need to be in the room to ask what it should do.
…communications needs to be more than a user of AI. It needs to be part of how AI is governed.
Communicators believe AI adoption has outpaced governance. Only 12% of Council Members agree that existing ethical policies are sufficient for AI adoption, while 76% disagree. Rather than signalling hostility towards AI, this suggests that organisations recognise the implications of getting it wrong. Ethical anxiety tends to grow when a technology moves from novelty to consequence. A tool used to polish a sentence can be managed informally. A tool used to draft crisis responses, simulate stakeholders, brief executives or shape reputation strategy cannot.
This is where “human in the loop” needs to mean more than a slogan. Unless the loop has been designed, this is not a safeguard. A junior employee approving an AI-generated statement they cannot verify is not governance. Nor is a senior leader glancing at a machine-written briefing without understanding its sources, assumptions or limitations.
Seen through this lens, Strategic Silence is not really a story about organisations speaking less. It is a story about harder decisions. The choice to speak, stay silent, engage, withdraw, accelerate or wait all require judgement. Communications leaders sit at the centre of those decisions.
With uncertainty now a permanent feature of the operating environment, a new premium is emerging: judgement. When information is abundant, content is cheap and answers are machine-generated, competitive advantage comes from knowing what to trust, which signals matter and how to act when certainty is unavailable.
This is the Judgement Economy. And in that economy, the value of communicators lies not in what they say, but in the quality of decisions they help organisations make.
Author: Ed Whitehead is an Advisory Director, Corporate Reputation at Ipsos in the UK, and editor of the Ipsos Reputation Council Report. Ed uses data and insights to help organisations understand and manage reputation as a strategic business asset. Before joining Ipsos, he spent more than 15 years in corporate and brand communications, blissfully unaware that reputation research was a thing.
Image: AI generated
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
